Help:Page validation

Editorial Review Process

The editor will be responsible for regularly determining the appropriateness of author edits, discussing the proposed changes, and finally approving a final set of changes. The instructions below will provide a guide to performing this process on the site, as well as instructions for setting up and configuring the features built into the site to improve this process for the editor. The basic process for monitoring and approving changes will utilize two main functions on the site:

Revision Tracking

The revision tracking feature will prevent author edits from moving to the live version of pages until the associate editor has approved the changes.

Watchlist

The watchlist is a list of pages chosen by the editor which will help keep the editor notified of page changes, and will provide a single webpage where the editor can view all pending changes. For initial setup and configuration of the watch, see the appendix below.

Watchlist

Essential steps:

• Log in! You can not see your watchlist if you are not logged in.
• Create your watchlist. A new user will not have any pages on their watchlist initially. You will need to add the desired pages to your watchlist. See the appendix below.
• Make sure your watchlist filter isn’t removing pages! For instance, in this example any changes older than 1 day would not appear in the watch list.

Approving Revisions:

1. The review status of each page is indicated on the top right.  After an author makes any edits, the status will be “review pending changes”, indicating that an editor needs to approve/disapprove the edits.
   
   Note, as the FlaggedRevs system was recently implemented, all pages are currently listed as “no review versions”.
   
   
2. As editors, click on “review pending changes”, which will allow you to see the differences between the original and the suggested revised page.  Two modes to do so: visual mode and wikitext mode. The default view is Wikitext, but once you click on Visual, the site should remember your last setting.
   
   
   1. Visual mode
      
      Red text means removed and the Green text means added. This will be the preferred method for most editors. The functionality will be similar to popular document creation software.
   2. Wikitext mode Editors can have more control if the switch to “wikitext” to view the differences in wiki syntax (for advanced editors this may be the best way to review long pages and also to spot syntax errors)
      
3. To approve/disapprove edits, go to the “review the revision” box at the bottom of the page.  IMPORTANT NOTE: You can only accept or reject all the new revision (cannot accept some and reject some) – if need to add only some of the changes, the editor will need to reject the revision and then manually re-edit the page to add in the new wanted changes.  
   1. Editors can choose the quality of the revision So something may be approved even though it is marked with a low quality in (let’s say) readability.
   2. If an editor chooses to disapprove the review, a comment can be made for the reasoning.
      
      Until revisions are approved, they will not appear as the default view for a page.
      
4. Once editorial review is complete, please indicate the date in the corresponding “Date of Last Editor Review” column of the Volunteer Assignments and Opportunities page.

Conversion Notes:

• • Note: Most testing for this process has used Google Chrome as the browser. Other browsers may have issues in transferring data between sections.

For the HAEM4 to HAEM5 book conversion, several key automatic processes have been performed:

1. HAEM4 pages have been assigned to HAEM5 counterparts when possible
   1. It is possible for a HAEM5 page to be entirely new, to need content brought in from more than one HAEM4 page, or for a single HAEM4 page to be divided into several HAEM5 pages. It is also possible for an original HAEM4 page to no longer be relevant, and therefore to not be assigned to a HAEM5 page.
   2. The automated process has attempted to uplift older templates to the current template when possible. This changes the structure of several key tables in particular. Please take the relevant content from each section and incorporate it into the new section.

1. If a HAEM5 page has one of more HAEM4 pages, the contents of one of the pages will have been automatically transferred. The relevant pages HAEM4 pages can be found in the conversion nots box at the top of each page. The first indicated page will have had its contents transferred. Other relevant pages will be listed as well. If relevant pages were empty or if no relevant pages were identified, there will not be a conversion box.

There are several ways to view the revisions. Each revision represents a single "save" by an author/editor. There may be multiple revisions to review, and each revision may have multiple changes within it. A visual representation of the changes can be used to select and approve a subset of the changes. However, for any revision to be accepted, all previous revisions must also be accepted. To visualize the changes, click on the “Browse history interactively” bar on the top and compare different versions: